Prequel to The Outlaw Josey Wales - Harriet the Spy Fan Reaction, Asa "Forrest" Carter

November 18, 2026 • 00:40:05
Prequel to The Outlaw Josey Wales - Harriet the Spy Fan Reaction, Asa "Forrest" Carter
This Film is Lit
Prequel to The Outlaw Josey Wales - Harriet the Spy Fan Reaction, Asa "Forrest" Carter

Nov 18 2026 | 00:40:05

/

Hosted By

Bryan Katie

Show Notes

- Patron Shoutouts

- Harriet the Spy  Fan Reaction

- Learning Things with TFIL: Asa "Forrest" Carter

- The Outlaw Josey Wales Preview


The Steve Index: 
https://engineer-of-souls.github.io/thisfilmislit

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:08] Speaker A: On this week's prequel episode, we follow up on our Harriet the Spy listener polls, learn about Forest Carter, and preview the outlaw Josie Wales. Hello, and welcome back to another prequel episode of this film is lit, the podcast where we talk about movies that are based on books. We got everything. Every single segment. Plenty to get to. Let's jump right in to our patron shout out. [00:00:32] Speaker B: I put up with you because your father and mother were our finest patrons. That's why. [00:00:37] Speaker A: No new patrons this week. But we do have our Academy Award winning patrons, and they are Amanda Nicole Goble, Harpo Rat. Read the Major Arcana by Jay Marbach and RW Meters Matters. I don't know how to. That's Nathan's name. He changed it for the first time in a while, I think. Matilde Cottonwood, Steve Ben Wilcox, Teresa Schwartz, Ian from Wine Country, Kelly Napier Gratch. Just scratch. Shelby says come back. AO3 and that darn skag. Thank you all very much for your continued support. I haven't heard the AO3 crash. [00:01:09] Speaker C: Oh, yeah, that's been like, a big thing [00:01:12] Speaker A: I didn't hear about. [00:01:14] Speaker C: It got, like, taken out by. It was this whole thing where it got, like, taken out and then some AI company had scraped the whole thing and was trying to, like, sell things back to people. [00:01:29] Speaker A: Geez Louise. [00:01:29] Speaker C: Yeah, but I. I think it came back up today. [00:01:32] Speaker A: Oh, okay. [00:01:33] Speaker C: I think so. I thought I saw something about that. [00:01:35] Speaker A: There we go. Hopefully it came back. Shelby. I hadn't. I hadn't heard about any of that. That's crazy. All right, let's go ahead and see what the people had to say about Harriet the Spy. [00:01:45] Speaker D: Yeah, well, you know, that's just like your opinion, man. [00:01:51] Speaker C: On Patreon. We had three votes for the book and zero for the movie. Kelly Napier said, I went back and forth on this as the book and the movie ended up pretty equally in quality for me. I decided to give my vote to the book because I really didn't like Harriet's Revenge tour in the movie. Not that a kid of that age wouldn't engage in emotionally irrational acts, because they totally would, but that she kept doing these things without any seeming consequence. She literally cut someone's hair and no adult punished her for this. That should have been the end of it right there. The teacher didn't notice her hit list carved on their desk. There's no way. [00:02:32] Speaker A: Yeah, there is no way. Yeah, [00:02:35] Speaker C: I mean, things were a little more lax [00:02:37] Speaker A: in the 90s, but not that much more lax. No, she would have gotten even if he wouldn't have been as big of a deal for the haircutting thing as it was today, she would have still gotten. [00:02:46] Speaker C: She would have [00:02:47] Speaker A: pretty [00:02:47] Speaker C: big [00:02:48] Speaker A: trouble. [00:02:48] Speaker C: Pretty deep. Doo doo. Yeah. The one thing in the book that I wish we had seen in the movie was Harriet practicing to be an onion. That could have been a funny scene and a way to show her parents do care about her despite their chronic absentee status. I agree. And I really think the movie needed [00:03:06] Speaker A: a [00:03:06] Speaker C: moment with her and her parents that was, like, light. Also, I didn't think it was necessary to change the family owning the deli from being Italian to being generically Asian instead of this change felt oddly racist for some reason, but I'm unable to find the words for some reason to explain why it felt that way to me. I don't think it was a necessary change. I wanted to bring it up because it felt like, really, for some reason, felt like a very 90s change [00:03:36] Speaker A: to [00:03:37] Speaker C: me. [00:03:38] Speaker A: And I don't know how generically Asian they are. I think they're specifically Chinese, but I could be wrong about that. I don't actually know. I'm saying that I'm just assuming that based on what we saw, like, I'm kind of assuming that I don't actually 100% know that that's the case. But, yeah, [00:03:54] Speaker C: And I do think that arguably both iterations are racist because the. Because the point is that they're exotic. [00:04:02] Speaker A: Yes, it's. At the very least, it's. It's. It's. I don't know if I would call it necessarily racist. I think there are definitely. There are racial shorthands and bigotries in the way that the family is depicted in the film in terms of, like. It's like, okay, yeah, sure, but. But it's also based on some real things. And, like, I do think there's like. Like, you know, like, the. The grandfather is doing cupping and acupuncture in, like, traditional Chinese medicines and stuff. But it's called traditional Chinese medicine for a reason. Those Chinese families do engage in that kind of stuff more than, like, there's this weird mixture. But there's also. We are shorthanding. We are condensing a lot of. [00:04:39] Speaker C: Yeah, [00:04:40] Speaker A: flattening a lot of the depiction of a family of that culture into kind of the most obviously recognizable stereotypes. Sorry, there's a lot of stereotyping. [00:04:48] Speaker C: Yes, there is [00:04:49] Speaker A: a lot of. That would be the way that I would describe it. [00:04:51] Speaker C: Stereotyping might be the better way to describe [00:04:53] Speaker A: it, as opposed to just outright racism, necessarily, which obviously stereotyping is a type of racism, but it's. It's more complicated than that, I would think. And I think the same thing for the Italian family. It's a little more playing on stereotypes. Yeah. Because [00:05:07] Speaker C: I don't think either iteration of this family is necessarily portrayed negatively. [00:05:13] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:05:14] Speaker C: But it is, like, the entire point, whether you're reading the book or watching the movie, is that they're, like, exotic and foreign. [00:05:21] Speaker A: Yeah. But I think even that. And this goes in a whole different direction, gets into this kind of. There's. There's. I. I don't know the best way to do it, necessarily. I mean, the best way to do it is by incorporating people from those cultures to make sure you're telling stories accurately or. Or whatever. But there is a degree of, like. I don't think the answer then, because it's. It's. It's like, well, we're including them because they're different and it's exotic or whatever. The answer then, well, we should just only have white people in the movie. I know. I know you're not saying that, but I'm saying I think there is a. A tension there between, like, you know, just, like, if we. Well, it's racist to, like, make them a Chinese family, or it's, like, potentially problematic to make them a Chinese family. And then. And again, this is not what Kelly is saying necessarily. But I also think at the same time that, I don't know, I had a direction, I was going with that, and then I lost it, and I got distracted, I got confused. So I don't know where I was gonna take that, but I had a point I was gonna make, and then I lost it. So we'll just move on. [00:06:21] Speaker C: I think there's a lot of fine lines in that. [00:06:23] Speaker A: Yes. Yeah. [00:06:25] Speaker C: Kelly went on to say in both the book and the movie, I didn't have any use for the day trip Gali took Harriet on. In the book, we meet Gali's mom and then never see. In the movie, we visit some eccentric artist, barely even interact with them, and then we never see them again. So what was the point? Also, if this movie were being made today, that eccentric artist would 100% be Gali's girlfriend or wife, not just a friend. And I would totally be here for that. [00:06:53] Speaker A: Yeah. Gali does code as. [00:06:55] Speaker C: Yeah. [00:06:57] Speaker A: Which, to be fair, maybe that's partially because she's played by Rosie o' Donnell in the film. But, like. [00:07:02] Speaker C: But I do think, yeah, she. She codes a little [00:07:05] Speaker A: gay. [00:07:06] Speaker C: A little gay, [00:07:07] Speaker A: yeah. [00:07:07] Speaker C: And the author of the book Also gay. [00:07:11] Speaker A: Makes sense. [00:07:12] Speaker C: I would be here for that adaptation, though. I would also actually be here for an adaptation that treated this as a period piece. I [00:07:22] Speaker A: think that [00:07:23] Speaker C: could be interesting. [00:07:23] Speaker A: In the 60s. Yeah. [00:07:24] Speaker C: That kind of leaned into the fact that the original story takes place in the 60s, I think. Could be interesting. Our other comment on Patreon was from Charlene, who said, I loved this book as a kid. Thanks for the excuse to revisit it. It's such a great slice of life. It captures both the routine and randomness of being a kid. I would love a version where she continues seeing that therapist. She probably should. Yeah. [00:07:53] Speaker A: Yeah. Well, maybe not that therapist, because his answer was, I saw you once, you're fine, apparently. [00:07:58] Speaker C: Yeah, maybe not that one, but some therapist would probably be. Maybe a good idea. Or maybe I just need the POV of all the adults in Harriet's life trying to figure out how she sees the world. We didn't have anything on Facebook this time on Instagram. We had two votes for the book, one for the movie, and one listener who couldn't decide. We had a typical Tim Wahoo quote who said, I always bet on Katie choosing the book. Sometimes [00:08:31] Speaker A: I do. I'll say, and if you did that, you would not win every bet. Probably win about half of them. If I had to guess, I don't know what the actual number is, but it's. It's maybe. Maybe not half. Maybe a slight edge towards. I guess it might be the better bet. [00:08:46] Speaker C: It would be the better bet. [00:08:47] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:08:48] Speaker C: Yeah, I have those numbers somewhere, but I don't have them broken down by who chose what. [00:08:52] Speaker A: Yeah. Because it includes mine, too. Yeah. Yeah. And I've definitely chosen them. I don't remember. Yeah. Anyways, [00:09:02] Speaker C: we didn't technically have any votes in our Threads poll, but we had a comment from MyBookish Years [00:09:09] Speaker A: who [00:09:09] Speaker C: said, the book, movie and TV series are all great. [00:09:13] Speaker A: Okay, [00:09:13] Speaker C: so I decided to [00:09:14] Speaker A: just mention the TV series. [00:09:15] Speaker C: Yeah. I decided to count that as a listener who couldn't decide. [00:09:18] Speaker A: Yeah, kind of sounds like it. [00:09:22] Speaker C: And finally, on Goodreads, we had one vote for the book, zero for the movie, and an uncharacteristically brief comment from Miko, who said, I did not have time to finish the book, but I'll still give my vote to it. [00:09:36] Speaker A: All right, fair enough. [00:09:39] Speaker C: So our winner this week was the book, with six votes to the movies one, plus two listeners who couldn't decide. [00:09:47] Speaker A: All right, we do have a Learning Things segment this week. We're going to learn a little bit about the author of our next book. [00:09:54] Speaker E: No matter what anybody tells you, words and ideas can change the world. [00:10:00] Speaker C: I don't know how to pronounce this man's first name, and I don't care. [00:10:04] Speaker A: Asa. [00:10:05] Speaker C: Asa. [00:10:06] Speaker A: I don't know. Who cares? Yeah. [00:10:07] Speaker C: Asa. Yeah. We're going to learn about Asa Forest Carter and strap in. [00:10:15] Speaker A: Yep. [00:10:16] Speaker C: Um, [00:10:16] Speaker A: we mentioned this in the last episode. We alluded to it. [00:10:19] Speaker C: Yeah. [00:10:19] Speaker A: This is where we're [00:10:20] Speaker C: at. Because this was not a good person. [00:10:25] Speaker A: No. [00:10:27] Speaker C: And I. [00:10:28] Speaker A: He's worse than you. [00:10:29] Speaker C: He's worse than you thought. [00:10:31] Speaker A: Yep. [00:10:31] Speaker C: He's worse than I thought. Before I started dipping my toes [00:10:36] Speaker A: into [00:10:36] Speaker C: that, I [00:10:37] Speaker A: knew most of this. [00:10:39] Speaker C: Yeah. If you could have seen me doing this research, you would have seen a very forlorn person. [00:10:46] Speaker A: Yep. [00:10:47] Speaker C: So [00:10:48] Speaker A: I think it's Asa. [00:10:49] Speaker C: Asa Carter. Also known as Forrest Carter, Also known as Ace, apparently. [00:10:56] Speaker A: Sure. [00:10:57] Speaker C: That [00:10:57] Speaker A: would make. I mean, [00:10:58] Speaker C: that [00:10:58] Speaker A: probably lends credence to it being Asa then. [00:11:01] Speaker C: Yeah. Asa. Asa Carter was an American segregationist, a Ku Klux Klan organizer, a white supremacist, and later a Western fiction novelist. Carter was born in Alabama in 1925. He served in the United States Navy during World War II as a radio operator. And it sounds like it's likely that this is where his slide into far right politics began. [00:11:29] Speaker A: Okay. [00:11:30] Speaker C: Because apparently during his time in service, the Office of Naval Intelligence was investigating a group of sailors on his ship who were meeting regularly to read and discuss American pro fascist writers. Oh, [00:11:45] Speaker A: they used to be against that back in the day. That's crazy. [00:11:47] Speaker C: Right? And then, according to one of Carter's brothers, Larry Carter, he rarely discussed politics before his time in the Navy, but afterwards, he could speak at length about far right activists and even encouraged Larry to read Mein Kampf. [00:12:05] Speaker A: Okay, [00:12:07] Speaker C: so here's a man who learned nothing from World War II. [00:12:11] Speaker A: No. [00:12:12] Speaker C: After his time in the Navy, he studied journalism for a year at the University of Colorado. Also apparently learned nothing doing that. Before getting married and settling down in Birmingham, Alabama, Carter worked for several area radio stations. Then before ending up at Station Wild in Birmingham, where he worked from 1953 to 1955. His broadcasts were sponsored by the American States Rights association, but his show was cancelled following community outrage, resulting in a station boycott over his estate. Over his attacks on National Brotherhood Week, an event which promoted friendship with the Jewish community. [00:12:57] Speaker A: Right. Yep. [00:12:59] Speaker C: Following that, Carter started a group called the North Alabama Citizens Council, which, from what I understand, was a splinter group that broke off from the Birmingham chapter of the Citizens Councils of America, which was a network of white supremacist segregationist groups. Apparently, he formed this group because he and the people in it with him wanted to focus on segregation, [00:13:28] Speaker A: and [00:13:28] Speaker C: they felt that the original Birmingham group was too focused on antisemitism. [00:13:33] Speaker A: Okay, so he hated Jews just. Yes. Like, he hated black people more. [00:13:38] Speaker C: He wanted to focus on black people more. [00:13:40] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:13:41] Speaker C: By March of 1956, he was making national news as a spokesman for segregation. Carter was quoted by United Press International as saying that the NAACP had, quote, infiltrated southern white teenagers with, quote, immoral rock and roll records. Carter. That called for jukebox owners to purge all records by black performers from their jukeboxes. Don't think they did, though. Later that year, Carter ran for a position on the Birmingham city commission as commissioner for public safety. He finished last in the primary for that election, which will be a recurring theme for him. [00:14:23] Speaker A: Yeah. Yeah. [00:14:25] Speaker C: Also then, during the mid-1950s, Carter founded a paramilitary KKK splinter group called the original Ku Klux Klan of the Confederacy. This group was later responsible for one attacking singer Nat King Cole on stage at a Birmingham concert, as well as an absolutely brutal attack on a black handyman named judge Edward Aaron Trigger. Warning, content, warning, [00:14:56] Speaker A: content, warning. [00:14:57] Speaker C: They castrated him, poured turpentine on his wounds, and then left him abandoned in the trunk of a car near Springdale, Alabama. Carter himself was not among the six men who did this, but it was his group. [00:15:11] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:15:12] Speaker C: Four of those men were sentenced to 20 years in prison. Those sentences were later commuted by the governor of Alabama in 1963. Obviously in 1958, Carter then quit the Klan group that he had founded after shooting two of its members in a dispute over finances. Those charges against him for doing that were also then dropped. It just [00:15:39] Speaker A: couldn't have happened to a nicer couple guys, I would imagine. [00:15:45] Speaker C: During the 1960s, Carter was a speechwriter for future Alabama governor George Wallace. He was one of two men credited with Wallace's infamous slogan, segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever, which was part of Wallace's 1963 inaugural speech. [00:16:04] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:16:05] Speaker C: Wallace would later deny that he knew Carter, which I think is really funny. [00:16:09] Speaker A: Hilarious. Yes. But, yeah, he. It's very well documented. I think it is a little bit mixed on, like, for sure that he was responsible for that line, but it is widely thought, like, I don't know if we have, like, super hard evidence that he pinned it, but he was a speechwriter at that time, and so people assume that he was at least somewhat responsible for that. [00:16:26] Speaker C: Involved to some degree. Yeah. [00:16:28] Speaker A: With that very famous slogan. [00:16:31] Speaker C: Carter then ran against Wallace for governor of Alabama in 1970 on a white supremacist platform and finished fourth in that primary. After losing that election, Carter moved to Abilene, Texas and quote, unquote, Abile, [00:16:49] Speaker A: I believe so [00:16:50] Speaker C: Abilene, Texas, where he quote, unquote, started over. He began work on his first novel, spending his days researching at the public library. He started to distance himself from his past and began referring to his sons as his nephews and renamed himself Forrest Carter, after Nathan Bedford Forrest, a general of the Confederate army and the first leader of the Ku Klux Klan. [00:17:18] Speaker A: Yeah, it is great that his rebrand was like, well, keep my last name. [00:17:22] Speaker C: Yeah. [00:17:22] Speaker A: And then I'll just change my first name to the name of a notorious. [00:17:26] Speaker C: Yeah. [00:17:27] Speaker A: Racist. Nobody will ever know. [00:17:29] Speaker C: Nobody will know. Nobody's going to suspect that it's me, guys. [00:17:32] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:17:33] Speaker C: Carter moved to St. George's Island, Florida in the 1970s where he completed a sequel to his first novel, as well as two books with Native American themes. He then separated from his wife who remained in Florida, and In the late 70s he settled in Abilene, Texas again. [00:17:54] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:17:56] Speaker C: Carter spent the last part of his life trying to conceal his background as a Klansman and a segregationist. Can't imagine why. Claiming categorically in a 1976 New York Times article that he, Forrest was not a [00:18:12] Speaker A: crazy lie to try to. [00:18:14] Speaker C: Yeah, I mean like I more get away able with then than it would be now, [00:18:20] Speaker A: but even [00:18:21] Speaker C: still like crazy to like take it to that level. [00:18:24] Speaker A: Especially again if you didn't even change your name that much and then you. The forest is after like again, I guess people wouldn't know at the time but why it was Forest. But like. Yeah, it's just crazy. I wonder how we know that he name. I wonder where that came from. The named himself Forest after the general of the Confederate army and first leader of the Ku Klux Klan. Just because if he was so adamant, maybe eventually he. [00:18:50] Speaker C: I don't know. [00:18:51] Speaker A: I don't know. That's just interesting. Or maybe a family member knew and [00:18:54] Speaker C: like [00:18:55] Speaker A: because I mean that's also in a part where it talks about how he started calling his. His kids nephew and so like maybe. [00:19:01] Speaker C: Yeah, [00:19:02] Speaker A: they in an interview talked about how that's how he picked the name or something. It was interesting if he went to his death pretending to be that he wasn't Asa Carter. I don't know. It's just interesting. [00:19:13] Speaker C: Okay, well Wikipedia cites that to a biography of him. [00:19:18] Speaker A: Okay. So maybe, [00:19:19] Speaker C: maybe there is some kind of. [00:19:21] Speaker A: They could have interviewed a family member or somebody who Knew. Or his wife or who knows. Yeah. [00:19:27] Speaker C: So this New York Times article. The article describes a 1974 interview of Carter by Barbara Walters on the Today show where Carter was, under his pen name Forest, promoting the rebel outlaw Josie Wales. And the Times reported that Carter, who had again had run for governor of Alabama just four years earlier, was identified by several Alabama politicians, reporters and law enforcement officials who had watched this episode of the Tate of the Today show as being the same person as Asa Carter. [00:20:04] Speaker A: I've seen that interview, clips from it. Yeah. [00:20:06] Speaker C: The article noted, quote, beyond denying that he is Asa Carter, the author has declined to be interviewed on the subject. [00:20:14] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:20:17] Speaker C: And then we have Carter's 1967 book, the Education of Little Tree, which is a memoir style novel that he claimed was a true story when first published. It was promoted as an authentic autobiography recounting Forrest Carter's youth experiences with his Cherokee grandparents in the Appalachian Mountains. He went to his grave claiming to have distant maternal Cherokee ancestry. And if you know anything about claims of specifically, like Cherokee ancestry by white Americans, you know how likely that is to be true. [00:20:55] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:20:55] Speaker C: But the Education of Little Tree was an entire literary fabrication. He was not orphaned at the age of five, nor was he raised by his grandparents, Cherokee or otherwise. And as far as I can tell from reading like the little bit about him that I did, he's never even been to Apple Latcha. [00:21:13] Speaker A: Yeah, [00:21:14] Speaker C: So [00:21:14] Speaker A: I read, I saw that that was the, the, the Education of Little Tree. I saw somewhere that that was at one point recommended. It was on Oprah's reading list. [00:21:26] Speaker C: Yeah. [00:21:26] Speaker A: Because it has [00:21:27] Speaker C: like, blew up after. [00:21:28] Speaker A: Supposedly has relatively not progressive but sympathetic and like, the message of it and its kind of depiction of Native Americans and stuff is not necessarily like. It's at least, I don't know, I don't know the way to describe it, but it's something that people who are ostensibly progressive were reading and seeing value in. And like I said, people like Oprah, she had it on her reading list and stuff. I don't know anything about the specifics of it, but she then had to take it off and [00:22:00] Speaker C: she removed her endorsement from that. [00:22:04] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:22:05] Speaker C: Yeah. He really just invented an entire new Persona for himself. [00:22:12] Speaker A: Yes. [00:22:13] Speaker C: Carter died in 1979. The official recorded cause of death was heart failure. However, there is lore about this [00:22:21] Speaker A: amazing. [00:22:22] Speaker C: Apparently the ambulance driver told one of Carter's friends that he had actually had a drunken fight with his son, fell, and then choked on his own vomit. [00:22:33] Speaker A: Good. [00:22:35] Speaker C: So I don't know. I'm gonna choose to believe that's yeah. I'm gonna have to believe that [00:22:39] Speaker A: that's how a guy, like, [00:22:41] Speaker C: looks poetic. I like that [00:22:43] Speaker A: a certain degree of. [00:22:44] Speaker C: Has a ring to it. [00:22:45] Speaker A: Yeah. It has the ring of truth, whether or not it is. Oh, boy. [00:22:52] Speaker C: Yeah. So that's Asa Carter. [00:22:53] Speaker A: Yeah. Yes. No, I. I knew most of this. I had been aware of most of this. Like I said, I'll recommend it. Again. There's a great video by the YouTube channel Atun Shea. A T U N hyphen S H E I History mainly focuses on, like Civil War in that era, like history stuff. But he has a video about the movie the Outlaw Josie Wales, and in it he kind of does this very fun reveal of who the author is over the course of this video. It's only like a 19, 20 minute video or something like that, but he goes into a lot of this backstory at different times and kind of talks about it, but also the kind of complicated element of that. He. There's maybe more nuance to later in life. Maybe he was potentially regretful about some of his earlier views and beliefs and was in fact trying to write stories that were rebuked that a little bit. Maybe, maybe not. It's. I don't know. Well, that again, I. I don't know enough about. I have not. I've not read the book. I haven't. Yeah. Anyways, I'm just going based on this one YouTuber who is generally pretty reliable in terms of their coverage of this kind of stuff. But anyways, yeah, that's. Yeah. What a guy. All right, well, let's learn a little bit about his book that we're going to talk about. Gone to Texas or the Rebel Outlaw Josie Wales. [00:24:24] Speaker F: Suddenly, his wife and child were dead. The feud was about to begin. [00:24:30] Speaker G: Hound, this wails to kingdom come because of what you did here today. I've got to kill that man. He'll have to run for it now. And hell is where he's headed. [00:24:43] Speaker F: Clint Eastwood is the outlaw Josie Wales. [00:24:46] Speaker C: Gone to Texas is a 1973American Western novel written by the aforementioned Asa Carter under the pen name Forest Carter. This was originally published under the title the Rebel Outlaw Colon Josie Wales, but was repackaged under Gone to Texas in 1975 for reasons unknown to me, because I could not find an explanation for it. I'm sure there is one somewhere, but I don't know what it is. [00:25:17] Speaker A: Keep going. I thought I. Did [00:25:19] Speaker C: you see something about [00:25:20] Speaker A: it? Wikipedia? I thought I saw something about the movie. [00:25:23] Speaker C: I would assume it's related to the movie for Some reason, because that's when they would have been making the movie, but I. I don't know. Yeah, [00:25:29] Speaker A: I don't know. [00:25:30] Speaker C: Carter began writing the novel sometime around 1967, when he was still working in politics. He finished the first hundred pages of the novel in 1973, after he had moved to Florida and established his new identity as Forrest Carter. He sent the manuscript to various publishers but was largely ignored. However, the editor of William Morris Agency's literary department, Rhonda Weir, expressed interest in the novel and encouraged him to give them the final manuscript. Carter finished the novel and sent Weir the final manuscript as requested. She then sent it a copy of it to Eleanor Freed, an editor at Delacorte Books. Fried was so enthusiastic about the book that she sent Carter a contract with an advance of $5,000, which was a pretty generous sum for first time authors. [00:26:26] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:26:27] Speaker C: Carter followed the novel with a sequel, the Vengeance Trail of Josie Wales, in 1976. And I had another. There was another thing on here that I didn't see in your notes, but I wanted to include it because I felt like it was maybe contradicted by something you had in your notes. And this is per the Wikipedia article for Asa Carter. It said Clint Eastwood directed and starred in a film adaptation of Josie Wales retitled the Outlaw Josie Wales. After Carter sent the book to his offices as an unsolicited submission and Eastwood's partner read it and put his support behind it. At this time, neither man knew of Carter's past as a Klansman and rabid segregationist, which is probably true. But then you had a note about the themes in the movie. [00:27:18] Speaker A: Yeah, well, we'll get to it. We'll get to that. I think that may be after, like the comment about the, like the stuff in the movie from the producer or the original director, I think may have been. In retrospect, he may have been saying those things. We'll get to it, assuming I know what you're talking about in my notes. I don't know for sure, but yeah, so I looked up, I don't know, the title change. It doesn't make any sense because they changed it away from [00:27:45] Speaker C: a [00:27:45] Speaker A: title that was closer to. [00:27:47] Speaker C: Closer to the movie. The [00:27:48] Speaker A: movie in a way that doesn't make sense. So I don't, I don't know why that changed. There must have been maybe some other legal thing or who knows? Because, yeah, like the year before the movie came out, they changed the book to Gone to Texas when it was originally called the Outlaw, [00:28:01] Speaker C: the [00:28:01] Speaker A: Rebel Outlaw Josie Wales. And the movie is called the Outlaw Josie Wales. So it's weird that they would have. Normally you would go the opposite. [00:28:07] Speaker C: It would have been called Gone [00:28:08] Speaker A: to Texas. And then they re released it as like. Yeah, I don't know. But yeah, we'll get into that other stuff here right now as we preview the film. The Outlaw Josie Wales. [00:28:19] Speaker H: Well, not a hard man to track. Leaves dead men wherever he goes. [00:28:27] Speaker G: Get out of the way. Holy. Whenever I get to liking someone, they ain't around long. [00:28:33] Speaker D: I notice when you get to disliking someone, they ain't around for long either. [00:28:41] Speaker G: Well, the one that everyone's so scared about. Yeah, [00:28:45] Speaker E: we got the Josie whales, Abe. We got reward money coming. You're wanted, Whales. [00:28:52] Speaker G: You a bounty hunter, [00:28:54] Speaker E: man. He's got to do something for a living these days, [00:28:57] Speaker G: Diane. Ain't much of a living, boy. [00:28:59] Speaker A: The Outlaw Josie Wales is a 19766 film directed by Clint Eastwood, known for Sully, American Sniper, Jersey Boys, Gran Torino, Letters From Iwo Jima, Flags of Our Father, Million Dollar Baby, Mystic River, Space Cowboys, and others. It was written by Philip Kaufman, known for Raiders of the Lost Ark, the Wanderers, and the Right Stuff, and Sonia Chernis, who wrote a couple episodes of rawhide and Mr. Ed and not much else so television. But yeah. The film stars Clint Eastwood, Chief Dan George, Sandra Locke, Bill McKinney and John Vernon, among quite a few others, has a 91% on Rotten Tomatoes, a 69 on Metacritic, and a 7.8 out of 10 on IMDb. It made 31.8 million against a budget of 3.7 million and was nominated for Best Original score at the 1977 Oscars. So screenwriter and original director Philip Kaufman, who is still accredited screenwriter, wanted the script to stay as close to the novel as possible, including keeping many of the characters and mannerisms for Josie Wales. But he was not a huge fan of the novel's political stance, saying it had been, quote, written by a crude fascist, end quote. And that the man's hatred of government was insane. End quote. He wanted to tone down that element of the script, but, quote, Clint didn't and it was his film, end quote. I assume that's what you're [00:30:16] Speaker C: talking [00:30:16] Speaker A: about. I wouldn't be surprised if that is kind of a retroactive view of, like, knowing he didn't. He found out later maybe about. And maybe he didn't know at the time any of, like, Forest Carter's background or anything. [00:30:31] Speaker C: Well, apparently a lot of people didn't. Yeah. [00:30:33] Speaker A: And maybe he. Maybe he had issues with the story that he wanted [00:30:37] Speaker C: to [00:30:37] Speaker A: Change. And then later he is now saying it was written by a crude fascist. Like, maybe years later he was asked about it because we're gonna get into why I said original director, and you'll note that I said that this film was directed by Clint Eastwood. We'll get into that here in just a second. So Sandra Locke was cast against Kaufman's wishes at one point as Laura Lee, who is the granddaughter of the old settler woman in the story. Sandra was 32 at the time, which is roughly 10 years older than the character is in the book. And Eastwood was the one who urged Kaufman to cast her and ended up entering into a relationship with Locke. And the two lived together despite [00:31:19] Speaker C: him [00:31:20] Speaker A: being married to Margaret Johnson. [00:31:22] Speaker C: Mess. [00:31:23] Speaker A: Oh, Clint Eastwood's relationship. He's been married. I have a note, a great little note here in a second from IMDb trivia, that is very funny. He's been married a million times during this. His marriage to Margaret Johnson had an open relationship, it would appear, at Eastwood's insistence, like, she just kind of allowed that to be the case. And so he was living with Sandra despite being married to this other woman. Sandra was also married to a man, but this was a gay man named Gordon Leigh Anderson that he. She had married years earlier for. As, like a marriage of convenience, I think, mainly kind of to be his beard, it sounds like potentially. So they were both married, but they were together for like, a decade, and there was stuff that would go on. Basically, people who knew him would say that he always described Sandra Locke specifically as like, the love of his life and like the one person that he ever. Blah, blah, blah, whatever. So the relationship between Philip Kaufman and Eastwood was very fraught on set, as Kaufman was initially the director for the film. And it was fraught for numerous reasons, including what I mentioned earlier, that they had disagreements about the script, but also supposedly Kaufman also had a crush on Sandra Locke and was jealous of her and Eastwood's relationship. Like I said, they also disagreed on many production issues. And eventually Eastwood just had a producer fire him at one point, and they filmed the scene without him, and he convinced one of the producers to just fire him. This caused a bunch of outrage with the Director's Guild, and the production ended up being fined. And it resulted in the Director's Guild passing a new rule which became known as the Eastwood Rule, which. Which prohibits an actor or producer from firing a director and then personally taking over the director's role because Clint Eastwood stepped in as director after that, from there on out, Eastwood would basically direct all his films. To avoid this issue getting into this one IMD trivia fact because I thought it was very funny. I don't know who wrote this. I don't even know. It's just somebody throwing shade at Clint Eastwood. This is directly as it reads on IMDb trivia. Clint Eastwood plays a man who loses his family. In real life, Eastwood has at least six families. Some estimates suggest as many as 14. [00:33:35] Speaker C: 14. [00:33:38] Speaker A: I thought that was fantastic. [00:33:40] Speaker C: Nobody needs that many families. Was [00:33:41] Speaker A: using IMDb trivia to just on Clint Eastwood for. Yeah, for a man who supposedly loves conservative values, he's doesn't apply that to his personal relationships. [00:33:53] Speaker C: Wow. That never happens. That never happens. Yeah. [00:33:57] Speaker A: So this film was included amongst The Film Institute's 1998 list of the 400 movies nominated for the top 100 greatest American movies. I assume that means it didn't make the [00:34:07] Speaker C: top one. Sounds like it didn't it like it made [00:34:09] Speaker A: the short [00:34:10] Speaker C: short list, but not the actual. Not the [00:34:12] Speaker A: actual list. I don't know. It was just on Wikipedia and then getting to a few reviews that I had to go pull pull quotes from Rotten Tomatoes because Wikipedia did not have very many pull quotes. Normally they do, which is nice. I just pull them from there. But I had to go under Rotten Tomatoes to get these. And these are all from later reviews. I didn't see any contemporary reviews on Rotten Tomatoes except for I guess Ebirds might be. But Dave Kerr for the Chicago Reader, I believe is what it was in 2011 wrote, quote, and these are all. Sorry, these first two are fresh reviews. Wales also possesses a touching emotional vulnerability that marks another significant step away from Eastwood's often over criticized macho image. End quote. Richard Schickel for the Time magazine wrote in 2008, quote, Eastwood gets to the heart of the matter, briskly orchestrates his confrontations intelligently and gets off without lingering unduly over the resultant ugliness. End quote. And then in a negative review, and it was a very short line that I pulled here, Richard Eater, writing for the New York Times in 2003, gave it a rotten rating and said, quote, a soggy attempt at a post Civil War western epic. [00:35:27] Speaker C: Soggy. [00:35:28] Speaker A: Called it soggy. [00:35:29] Speaker C: Interesting. [00:35:30] Speaker A: And then finally Ebert gave it three out of four stars and said, quote, Eastwood is such a taciturn and action oriented performer that it's easy to overlook the fact that he directs many of his movies and many of the best, most intelligent ones. Here with the moody, gloomily beautiful photography of Bruce Surtees. Bruce. Bruce Surtees. He creates a magnificent western feeling. End quote. And was very positive on the film overall. I have heard very good things about this movie. Before we get to that, we wanted to remind you you can do us a favor by heading over to Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Blue Sky, Goodreads, any of those places. Follow us, interact. We'd love to hear from you. You can Support [email protected] ThisFilmIsLit and if you support us at the $15 a month level, you can get access to patron priority requests, which this in fact was. [00:36:15] Speaker C: This was a request from Gratch. Just Gratch. [00:36:21] Speaker A: There you go. That's surprising because on the reveal post for this, Nathan was like, this is one of my favorite movies. So I was, I think it was Nathan that said that. So surprised to see that he wasn't the one that requested it. [00:36:33] Speaker C: But [00:36:33] Speaker A: anyways, [00:36:34] Speaker C: this is Gratch's first [00:36:36] Speaker A: request [00:36:37] Speaker C: in a while, I think. [00:36:38] Speaker A: Where can people watch? [00:36:40] Speaker C: Well, as always, you can check with your local library. I bet they can get you a copy of this. [00:36:45] Speaker A: Yes, I would imagine. [00:36:47] Speaker C: Or a local video rental store if you still have one. You can also apparently stream this for free with ads on YouTube. [00:36:55] Speaker A: Oh, okay. [00:36:56] Speaker C: Or you can rent it for around $5 from Prime Video, Apple TV or Fandango Stream. [00:37:04] Speaker A: Okay. But what I was saying was that I have heard. I'm interested to watch this because I have heard from several places people saying this is a very good movie and that it's even despite maybe it's surface level politics, that at its core it is a. A it. There's like a kind of a dissonance and a clash between maybe its surface level politics and its actual politics and like what it's saying and what it's doing. Again, the. The attention shade handle I mentioned, he's a huge fan. I think it's one of his favorite movies and he is very much not sympathetic to the Lost Cause myth or the Confederacy or anything like that. Very much the opposite. But he, in that video that I mentioned, he holds this up as an example of a good, a very good film about like a Confederate protagonist compared to other films like I think Gods and Generals or whatever. There's some other big movie that came out in like the early 90s. [00:38:00] Speaker C: Yeah, [00:38:00] Speaker A: that is very much like a propaganda piece for like the Lost Cause. Whereas this, while has having some sympathies to characters who are Confederate or ex Confederate soldiers or whatever, does it in a much more humanistic and even, maybe not even handed, but in a way that acknowledges kind of the history in a way that doesn't minimize. I don't know, it's hard to describe. I haven't seen the film so I'm just going based off like this, this video. But I, I am very interested to watch it because of that. Because again, the little bit I know of the story is I can understand why it, it's not like a. As a very left leaning show. The kind of inherent story of this is not something I'm deeply sympathetic to but I am very interested to see from what I have heard or what I vaguely know of the story. But I am interested to see where it goes and how it plays out because again people who I know also share similar politics to politics to us say this movie is very good and is like doing interesting things. Yeah. Anyways, have you started the book yet? [00:39:10] Speaker C: I have not and I'm not looking forward to it. I've flipped through it a little bit and some of the things that I saw in that flip through I was like, [00:39:20] Speaker A: yeah, yeah, [00:39:22] Speaker C: but I'll power through. [00:39:25] Speaker A: All right. [00:39:26] Speaker C: It's like 200 pages. I'll get it done. [00:39:28] Speaker A: Yeah. So a day or two late next week we'll see how that goes. But come back next week we're talking about the outlaw Josie Wales. Until that time, guys, gals, non binary pals and everybody else [00:39:40] Speaker C: keep reading books, [00:39:40] Speaker A: keep watching movies and keep [00:39:42] Speaker C: being awesome. Sam.

Other Episodes

Episode 203

June 30, 2021 • 02:17:47
Episode Cover

Hatchet

Here it was. The Episode. The Episode, which he had been excited to do. The Episode about his favorite childhood book. The book that...

Listen

Episode 70

January 01, 2019 • 01:00:30
Episode Cover

Prequel to #39 - Q&A, Mary Poppins Preview

- **We answer all of your questions!** - ***Mary Poppins*** Preview

Listen

Episode 6

October 24, 2017 • 01:04:32
Episode Cover

#6 Coraline

A brave little girl, a sarcastic cat, and a fantasy-world that isn’t quite what is seems. It’s Katie’s favorite book, it’s **_Coraline_** , and...

Listen